Two recent releases give directors and health and safety professionals a useful view of safety culture: the Institute of Directors' Health and Safety Governance: A Good Practice Guide (written with WorkSafe) and Safe365's Safety Culture Maturity Insights Report 2024. The Safe365 report draws on data from 2,672 organisations across New Zealand, Australia and the UK. Set beside the IoD guide it gives a clear picture of where most organisations actually start and what it takes to lift safety culture from there.
The Bedrock of Safety: Understanding Governance and Legal Obligations
The Health and Safety at Work Act 2015 doesn't ask directors to guarantee compliance. It requires every officer to exercise due diligence to make sure the business meets its duties. The IoD guide is clear that understanding this duty is the starting point for building due diligence into how the organisation runs. The Act spells out what that includes: keeping health and safety knowledge up to date, understanding the operations and their hazards and risks, making sure the right resources and processes are in place and used, then verifying it.
Safe365's report shows a real gap here, with director and management knowledge averaging just Tier Three on its five tier maturity scale. That suggests many senior leaders aren't yet set up to lead from the top and it holds back safety culture maturity across the whole organisation.
Learn about Advanced Safety and Safe365's long-standing partnership here.
Setting Expectations and Governance Processes
Clear roles and responsibilities are the foundation of good safety governance. The IoD guide advises defining them at both executive and governance level and setting up governance processes for health and safety policy and objectives, with regular governance meetings and structured reporting doing much of the work.
Safe365's data shows weaknesses in governance processes across many organisations. Director inductions average just 42% and management inductions 51%. Better induction programmes look like one of the simplest places to lay the foundation for good safety governance.
Risk Management and Assurance
Risk management sits at the heart of safety culture. The IoD guide puts the focus on critical risks and on making sure the key controls are actually applied, with regular audits and external reviews to keep those controls honest.
Safe365's findings back this up, with risk management expertise averaging only 44% for both management and directors. That points to a need for better training and a deeper understanding of risk management at leadership level. The report also stresses the importance of talking about risk tolerance, noting that “low levels of maturity here suggest our value sets around health and safety don't fully address the company position between people and profitability.”
Internal and External Assurance and Verification
One of the biggest shortfalls Safe365 found is the lack of internal and external assurance and verification. Verification and audit scored just 38.7% and it was the lowest scoring element in every industry, a sign that the focus still sits on responding to incidents instead of preventing them. Many organisations simply don't have the mechanisms in place to show their safety systems work the way they're meant to.
To close that gap, organisations should focus on two things:
Implement a Comprehensive Assurance Programme: Combine internal audits, inspections and external reviews to check that your health and safety system actually works.
Focus on Proactive Measures: Shift from reactive to proactive safety management by stress testing your controls regularly and checking that work is done the way the procedure says it should be.
Employee and Contractor Engagement
Engaging workers and contractors in safety conversations is where safety culture is actually built. The IoD guide points boards toward formal worker representation alongside more informal engagement, asking workers about the realities of the job and making sure policies are practical enough to work.
Safe365's data shows significant gaps in contractor management and engagement. The average maturity score for contractor management systems is just 43% and 18 of the 20 industries sit at Tier Three or below. That leaves plenty of room to lift how contractors are managed and engaged.
Proactive Behaviours and Continuous Improvement
The IoD guide pushes for insightful reporting and constructive responses to issues, building a culture of continuous improvement. Safe365's report shows many organisations struggle with proactive behaviour and monitoring, with practice assurance averaging 33% and control effectiveness 34%. Systems may be in place, however they aren't always being used the way they were designed.
Safe365's weakest scores sit in the areas that measure proactive behaviour, the gap between work as imagined and work as done. The report's own conclusion is that we're still far from proactive safety cultures. Stress testing and practice assurance can show whether emergency preparedness and safety controls really work, turning safety from a reactive task into an everyday habit.
Where Does Safety Culture Currently Stand?
The IoD guide gives directors a framework to align their effort and resources to. Set beside the Safe365 data it suggests the vast majority of organisations, large and small, are stuck at Tier Three, the Systemic tier, with systems in place and proactive behaviour still to come.
Safety Culture Insights by Industry
Safe365's data gives a benchmark across industries and maturity varies a lot between them. Mining and hospitality lead the way, while arts and recreation, IT and media and public services trail behind, barely reaching Tier Three. That spread is a good reason to shape your approach around the risks in your own industry and borrow what's working elsewhere.
Practical Steps to Improve Safety Culture
Enhance Induction Programmes
Improve Risk Management Practices
Engage Employees and Contractors
Focus on Continuous Improvement
Use Industry Insights
Implement Internal and External Assurance and Verification Mechanisms
The Safety Culture Journey Ahead
Shifting the dial from reactive safety to an embedded safety culture takes a commitment to continuous learning, proactive behaviour and genuine worker engagement. Set clear expectations, tighten governance processes and focus on critical risk. Do that consistently and safety culture starts to lift.
Read together, the IoD guide and the Safe365 report show what good looks like and how far most organisations still have to go. Directors and health and safety professionals who act on both can move safety culture from a regulatory requirement to part of how the organisation actually works.
Want to know where you currently stand?
If you'd like to know where your organisation sits against this data, Safe365's own maturity assessment measures the same elements this article draws on.
How I Measure Safety Culture Beyond the Scorecard
Maturity data like Safe365's is useful because it shows the pattern, however a score on its own can't tell you why your organisation sits where it does. In Raise the Standard I describe the Compliance Compass, the structured diagnostic behind most of the assessments in the book, built to answer exactly that question.
It looks at four layers in a single engagement: what governance believes is happening, what the documents claim, what practice on the ground reveals and what the evidence can actually support. Each layer is scored against a maturity model and the gaps between them show up as plainly as the scores. My experience is that safety culture really lives in the distance between what the board believes and what happens at the coal face.
If you want a quick first look at those gaps in your own organisation, the free G.A.P.E. Self-Assessment takes you through the same four layers.
Frequently Asked Questions About Safety Culture
What is safety culture?
Safety culture is the shared attitudes, beliefs and behaviours that shape how people actually work around risk from one day to the next. It goes beyond having compliant systems on paper and covers whether those systems are used, how leaders behave and whether people feel able to speak up. The real test is what happens when nobody is watching and production pressure is on.
How do you measure safety culture?
Most organisations use a maturity assessment, worker perception surveys and audits that compare work as done with work as imagined. Tools like Safe365's maturity scale score elements such as leadership, risk management and verification to give a benchmark against other organisations. The most reliable picture comes from checking evidence in the field, not just what reports and policies say.
What is the role of directors in safety culture?
Directors and other officers have a personal due diligence duty under the Health and Safety at Work Act 2015 to make sure the business meets its health and safety duties. That includes understanding the operations and their risks, making sure the right resources and processes are in place and verifying they're being used. The way a board asks questions and responds to bad news sets the tone for the whole organisation.
About the Author

Matt Jones is the founder of Advanced Safety and a HASANZ-registered health and safety consultant. He's a Professional Member of NZISM and holds a Graduate Diploma in Occupational Safety and Health.
He advises boards, directors and executives on officer due diligence and critical risk under the Health and Safety at Work Act 2015. His book Raise the Standard: Why Good Organisations Go Blind and How Leaders Restore Visibility sets out G.A.P.E.™, F.E.E.D.™ and S.A.F.E.T.Y.™, a leadership architecture framework for high-risk organisations.
He created the Compliance Compass audit and hosts the Health & Safety Unplugged podcast.
Keep reading
Governance Advisory
Is the health and safety report your board reads actually true?
Your officers carry a personal due diligence duty under the Health and Safety at Work Act 2015. Governance Advisory puts an independent view over your critical risk reporting every month and a short paper in front of your board every quarter, giving the people who sign off a true picture of what’s going on.
Start with the free Officer Due Diligence Check or read the Colliers Project Leaders case study.
Latest update: 5 November 2026
