Skip to main content
HSWA 2015Risk ManagementWorkSafe NZISO 45001RiskSafety CultureConstructionHealth and safetyHSWAPCBUSafetyTrainingContractor ManagementHealth and Safety TrainingJSALawPPESafety management systemsSafety TrainingCommitteeCommunicationDownstreamEmergency PlanHazardHazardous SubstancesHealth and safety in constructionHealth and Safety LeadershipHealth and Safety RepresentativeHolidaysHSCHSRRegulationsRepresentativesSafety CommunicationSWMSUpstreamWorker EngagementWorkSafeACC AEPAi in safetyArtificial intelligenceAuditsBest PracticesBoard of trusteesCampingCase LawChange ManagementChristchurch SafetyCommunityCompetencyCompliance PulseConfined SpacesConstruction Health and SafetyContractorsControlCritical riskCultureEffective safety auditsEfficiencyElectricityEmergency Response PlansEmployee productivityEmployee safetyEmployees health and safetyExecutiveGovn365HASANZHazardsHealth and Safety Amendment Bill 2026Health and safety capabilityHealth and safety careersHealth and Safety CommitteeHealth and Safety ConsultantHealth and Safety ConsultantsHealth and Safety Contractor ManagementHealth and safety coursesHealth and Safety PolicyHealth and Safety ProfessionalsHealth and safety regulationsHealth and Safety ServicesHealth and Safety SignageHealth and safety systemHierarchyHierarchy of controlHSEAHSNOJob Safety AnalysisKiwi rail prosecutionLeadershipLeadership coursesLegalManagement of ChangeMental HealthMental Health First AidNeurodiversityNZ HolidaysNZHSPNZHSP ConnectOccupational safety trainingOffice Health and SafetyPermit To WorkPINSPolicyPreQualificationProfessional developmentProfessionalsProsecutionPsychologically Safe WorkplaceQualify365ReformRisk RegisterRPESafeSafe365Safety auditSafety capabilitySafety ConnectSafety controlsSafety DataSafety Data SheetsSafety in ConstructionSafety in the workplaceSafety lawSafety NewsSafety policySafety precautionsSafety ReformSafety ServicesSafety systemSafety TalksSite app proSMSToolbox talksTotikaUnderstanding health and safetyVolunteersWork SafeWorking at HeightsWorkplace accidentsWorkplace hazardsWorkplace safety
TAGS

Hierarchy Of Control: How To Manage Workplace Risk

Hierarchy of Control

The hierarchy of controls is the order a PCBU works through to manage a workplace risk under New Zealand law: eliminate the risk first and where that isn't reasonably practicable, minimise it by substitution, isolation or engineering controls, then administrative controls, with personal protective equipment (PPE) as the last line of defence. Elimination comes from section 30 of the Health and Safety at Work Act 2015 (HSWA) and the order of the remaining controls is set by regulation 6 of the General Risk and Workplace Management Regulations 2016. That's why PPE on its own is only acceptable once every higher control has been considered.

You'll often see the hierarchy drawn online as an inverted pyramid. The idea is the same, however under HSWA it's applied to risk instead of hazards alone and each step only applies if some risk remains after the one above it.


The hierarchy of control under HSWA 2015 is a risk-based framework that prioritises elimination first, then substitution, isolation or engineering controls, followed by administrative controls, with PPE used only as a last line of defence.

Hierarchy of Control and Managing Workplace Risk Under HSWA 2015

Under Regulation 6 of the Health and Safety at Work (General Risk and Workplace Management) Regulations 2016, PCBUs must eliminate risks so far as is reasonably practicable. If elimination isn't reasonably practicable, risks must be minimised using one or more of the following controls:

  • Substitution

  • Isolation

  • Engineering controls

In New Zealand these three sit at the same level and one isn't automatically better than another, the correct control depends on the nature of the risk and the work being done.

Only where risk remains should administrative controls be applied, with PPE used as the final layer.

Elimination in the Hierarchy of Control: Removing Risk at Source

Elimination Hierarchy of Control

Elimination is the most effective way to manage workplace risk, if the risk is removed entirely there's nothing left to manage.

Examples of elimination in practice include:

  • Designing out hazardous tasks during project planning

  • Removing hazardous substances from a process entirely

  • Eliminating the need to work at height through equipment redesign

Under HSWA 2015, elimination must always be considered first, even if it's ultimately deemed not reasonably practicable.

Though not always possible, this approach should be the first consideration during any risk assessment.

Substitution in the Hierarchy of Control for Managing Risk

Substitution Hierarchy of Control

Substitution involves replacing a risk with a lower-risk alternative. Under HSWA 2015, substitution is one of the primary methods for minimising risk when elimination isn't achievable.

Examples include:

  • Substituting solvent-based products with water-based alternatives

  • Replacing manual handling with mechanical aids

  • Using quieter equipment to reduce noise exposure

Substitution doesn't remove risk entirely, however it can significantly reduce both likelihood and consequence.

Isolation in the Hierarchy of Control: Separating People From Risk

Isolation Controls, Hierarchy of Controls

Isolation controls risk by separating workers from the source of harm. Under the current legislation isolation sits level with engineering controls, not subordinate to them, it's an equally valid risk minimisation option.

Examples include:

  • Physical barriers or exclusion zones

  • Remote operation of plant or equipment

  • Traffic separation between vehicles and pedestrians

Isolation is particularly effective where risk cannot be eliminated or substituted but can be physically contained.

Engineering Controls in the Hierarchy of Control Framework

Engineering Controls Hierarchy of Control

Engineering controls reduce risk through physical design or modification and work by reducing exposure instead of relying on human behaviour.

Common engineering controls include:

  • Machine guarding

  • Local exhaust ventilation

  • Automated shutdown systems

  • Noise enclosures

Engineering controls are often more reliable over time because they don't depend on individual compliance.

Administrative Controls in the Hierarchy Of Control

Administrative Control Hierarchy of Control

Administrative controls change the way work is performed. Under HSWA 2015, they must only be relied on after higher-order controls have been considered.

Examples include:

  • Safe work procedures

  • Training and competency systems

  • Permits to work

  • Rostering to manage fatigue

Administrative controls are important but fragile, they need ongoing supervision, reinforcement and review to stay effective.

PPE in the Hierarchy of Control: The Last Line of Defence

Personal Protective Equipment (PPE) sits at the bottom of the hierarchy of control and should never be the primary risk control.

Limitations of PPE include:

  • It doesn't eliminate risk

  • It relies on correct selection, fit and use

  • It can fail through wear, misuse or fatigue

PPE should be used to supplement, not replace, higher-order controls.

How to Apply the Hierarchy Of Control in the Workplace

To correctly apply the hierarchy of control under HSWA 2015:

  1. Identify the risk, not just the hazard

  2. Attempt elimination first and document whether it's reasonably practicable and why

  3. Select substitution, isolation and engineering controls as appropriate

  4. Layer administrative controls where residual risk remains

  5. Use PPE only as a final defence

This approach aligns with WorkSafe guidance and legislative expectations.

Then monitor and review.

Ask whether the controls are actually working and what's changing in your environment, safety isn’t “set and forget.” Regular reviews are critical.

The Hierarchy Of Control and Legal Compliance

New Zealand's HSWA 2015 requires a proactive approach to risk management. Following the hierarchy of control supports your PCBU (Person Conducting a Business or Undertaking) duties under the Act, particularly:

  • Section 30: Managing risks

  • Section 36: Primary duty of care

  • Section 45: Worker responsibilities

  • Regulations 6-9: Risk management requirements

PCBUs must eliminate risks so far as is reasonably practicable. Where elimination isn't possible they must apply the hierarchy of controls in order, document why higher-order controls can't reasonably be used and make sure controls are maintained and reviewed.

Failing to consider higher-level controls before defaulting to PPE can lead to enforcement actions by WorkSafe NZ.

Common Mistakes When Using the Hierarchy of Control

Mistake 1: Using the Old Hazard Pyramid

Many organisations still reference the pre-2015 inverted hierarchy and it doesn't meet HSWA expectations, it can undermine risk assessments too.

Mistake 2: Treating Substitution, Isolation and Engineering as Ranked

Under HSWA 2015, these controls are equal options, not a strict ranking.

Mistake 3: Jumping Straight to PPE

PPE without higher-order controls is a warning sign during audits, investigations and prosecutions.

Hierarchy of Control in Construction, Manufacturing and Infrastructure

Construction example: Working at height

  • Elimination: design to avoid height work

  • Substitution: use prefabrication at ground level

  • Isolation: guardrails and edge protection

  • Engineering: scaffolding systems

  • Administrative: permits and supervision

  • PPE: harnesses

Manufacturing example: Chemical exposure

  • Elimination: remove hazardous chemical

  • Substitution: lower-toxicity product

  • Engineering: ventilation systems

  • Isolation: enclosed processes

  • Administrative: exposure limits and training

  • PPE: gloves and respirators

What the KiwiRail Fall Teaches About the Hierarchy of Control

In October 2023 a worker fell 10 metres while installing a new telecommunications pole for KiwiRail in Whanganui and suffered serious injuries. WorkSafe found there was no specific risk assessment or procedure for the new pole design, the climbing pegs were installed incorrectly and a fall arrest system was fitted but not in use. Safer options such as a mobile elevated work platform weren't provided. KiwiRail was fined $220,000 in November 2025.

Every one of those failings sits low on the hierarchy of control. The work relied on climbing and a harness when an elevated work platform could have taken the worker off the pole altogether. WorkSafe's Nigel Formosa put it plainly: "When you introduce new infrastructure, you can't assume existing procedures will be adequate."

It's one of the cases I use in Raise the Standard because nothing in it was dramatic. Small failings lined up, each one defensible on its own, until the only control left was a fall arrest system nobody was using.

If you want to see how your own controls stack up, the free Compliance Compass Self-Check is a quick way to see whether they work on site the way they read on paper.

Frequently Asked Questions About the Hierarchy of Control

What are the levels of the hierarchy of control?

The first step is to eliminate the risk where you can. If that isn't reasonably practicable, you minimise it with substitution, isolation or engineering controls. In New Zealand those three sit at the same level. Administrative controls come next and PPE is the last line of defence.

Is the hierarchy of control a legal requirement in New Zealand?

Yes, the Health and Safety at Work (General Risk and Workplace Management) Regulations 2016 set out the order in which controls must be considered when a risk can't be eliminated.

Is PPE ever enough on its own?

Only once higher-level controls have been considered and aren't reasonably practicable. Defaulting to PPE without considering higher-level controls can lead to WorkSafe enforcement action.

Final Thoughts on the Hierarchy of Control and Managing Workplace Risk

The hierarchy of control is a thinking framework for managing risk under HSWA 2015 and treating it as a diagram to tick off misses the point. Applied correctly it drives better decisions, stronger systems and defensible compliance.

If your risk documentation still references the old hazard-based hierarchy, now is the time to update it.

About the Author

Matt Jones, founder of Advanced Safety, HASANZ registered, ProfNZISM, Graduate Diploma in Occupational Safety and Health

Matt Jones is the founder of Advanced Safety and a HASANZ-registered health and safety consultant. He's a Professional Member of NZISM and holds a Graduate Diploma in Occupational Safety and Health.

He created Compliance Compass, the independent audit Advanced Safety uses to show leaders what's actually happening on site against what the documents say. The thinking behind it sits in his book Raise the Standard: Why Good Organisations Go Blind and How Leaders Restore Visibility, built on three frameworks: G.A.P.E.™ finds where visibility is lost, S.A.F.E.T.Y.™ designs the leadership architecture that closes the gap and F.E.E.D.™ keeps it closed.

He also hosts the Health & Safety Unplugged podcast.

Keep reading

Compliance Compass

Does your health and safety system work the way it reads on paper?

Compliance Compass is an independent audit of your health and safety system, delivered in four weeks and assessed against ISO 45001 and the Health and Safety at Work Act 2015. You see what’s really happening on site and in the documents, with a clear view of what to fix first.

If you’re not ready for that yet, start with the free Compliance Compass Self-Check or browse the case studies.

Latest update: 10 November 2026



 

This product has been added to your cart

CHECKOUT